What is the difference between red oak and white oak hardwood? By Debbie Gartner

Posted on Posted in FAQ ABOUT WOOD FLOORS, Wood Floors New York City

What is the difference between red oak and white oak hardwood?

red oak vs white oak hardwoodOak flooring is the most popular species of hardwood here in Westchester County NY and the northeast in general. Oak is a very practical wood, is readily available (grown and made in the US), very affordable and very easy to stain so you can find the color you prefer. But many consumers don’t realize that there are 2 species of oak – red oak and white oak flooring.

If you are installing new hardwood flooring everywhere, either red oak hardwood or white oak hardwood will work, and your choice will probably be dependent on which look/color you prefer as well as the price (the prices of red oak/white oak fluctuate, so in general there is not usually a major price difference, but this can vary slightly at any given time frame or based on the brand/grade/width of hardwood you are choosing.

If you already have oak flooring, and are adding additional oak flooring, you will want to match what you already have…that way, you will have a consistent look and wood will absorb the stain colors the same way.I’ve seen it happen too often where a customer (or contractor) has mismatched the wood with red oak in some areas and white oak in others. This means that your wood will never completely match – the graining will be different and the stain color will be different.

What’s the difference between red oak flooring and white oak flooring?

Red Oak flooring – select grade                                                               White Oak flooring – select grade

Red oak hardwood floors westchester countyWhite oak hardwood flooring - Westchester NY - Select grade1.  Color – red oak has a bit of a pinkish tint is a little bit lighter than white oak. White oak tends to be a bit browner, darker and more yellow. As they start out with different colors and have different densities, red oak and white oak absorb stains differently.  When you stain them, the difference between the 2 species decreases, especially the darker you go. With lighter stains, the red oak tends to have a bit of red undertone in the color.

 

2.  Graining red oak tends to have stronger graining than white oak hardwood. White oak has a bit of a smoother look. Some people prefer the strong graining of red oak – both because they like the look and because the strong graining helps hide the scratches and dents; other prefer the slightly smoother grain of white oak and feel it’s a less busy look. 

 

White oak has more mineral streaks (and this gives it a bit more of a contemporary look).  Also, the rays are a bit longer on white oak vs red oak.

 

Red oak vs white oak hardwood floors westchester county3. Hardness – white oak flooring is a bit harder than red oak. On the Janka hardness scale, White oak is 1360 and red oak is 1290. But, as I mentioned above, even though red oak is a bit less hard, it tends to show the dents a bit less.

 

4.  Compatibility with stair treads and accessoriesRed oak is more common in stair treads, saddles, banisters and other transitions. If you have oak stair treads already in your home, chances are, they are red oak, so you may be better served matching that. If you need to get new stair treads or other transitions, they are usually more readily available (and hence lower priced) in red oak.

 

red oak vs white oak hardwood flooring5.  White oak is more resistant to water than red oak.  Because white oak is a closed grain wood, it more impervious to water.  Many of pores are plugged with tyloses making it more resistant to decay and rot.  This is why it’s used more often in boat building.  And, it’s also why it’s better to use white oak on front door jambs as well as other areas that may be more exposed to water and nature’s elements. 

 

You can see a great demonstration on the porousity of red oak and white on this ship building video.  It’s amazing to see how much faster the red oak absorbs the water.  It’s quite amazing.

 

red oak compared to white oak flooring6.  Price – In general, there is not a major price difference between red oak and white flooring. Because unfinished hardwood is a commodity item, the price tends to fluctuate weekly. At times, red oak costs more; at other times, white oak costs more. the price will often vary based on width and grade. And, very often, I have the red oak in 1 size as more expensive and white oak of another size is more expensive, and it literally changes all the time. 

 

That being said when looking at wider planks, especially 5″ and wider, white oak tends to be a bit more expensive. That is most like due to most red oak trees grow taller and have a wider diameter, as well as the fact that red oak is more abundant vs. white oak (at least in the US).

 

Please note that matching hardwood is a bit more complex than simply matching red oak vs. white oak. Also, there are differences in grades of hardwood flooring (e.g. select grade vs No 1 vs. No 2 vs quarter-sawn). If you are unsure what type of flooring you have, it’s best to call in an hardwood flooring expert.

 

Also, bear in mind that you can stain both red oak and white oak flooring to be darker.  They both accept the stain colors a bit different, so it’s important to test them on your floors.  White oak tends to come out a bit darker and browner while red oak tends to come out a bit lighter and has a bit of red undertones.  You tend to notice the red undertones more in red oak with lighter stains; the darker you go, the more it drowns out the pink/red.  Below are all examples of oak with stains.

Hardwood flooring poll

Red Oak - Shaw Eagle RidgeRed oak eagle ridge from Shawsomerset charcoal gray oak homestylered oak vs white oak floors

 

 

 

 

 

For those looking to go gray, white oak works much better.  The color and the graining just work better with this cool tone. And, with red oak, there is an underlying pinkish tint, so you need to go darker with the gray to drown it out.  You can learn more about gray hardwood floors here.

 

Conclusion:  Both red and white oak are great options.  Some people prefer the look of red oak while others prefer white oak.  If you are starting from scratch, pick your favorite.  If you are adding to existing hardwood, it’s generally best to match.  Here are some tips on matching new and existing hardwood floors.

 

When you’re looking to refinish your hardwood floors in Westchester County, give The Flooring Girl a call at 914-937-2950.  (Out of area callers, please dial 914-407-3899).

schedule free flooring consultation2

For more info, check out my Ebook – Top 6 Hardwood Refinishing FAQ’s.

ebook - Top 6 Hardwood flooring FAQ's blue

 

You may also find these hardwood flooring articles helpful:

Leave a Reply